Clevenger Insurance Agency


Clevenger Insurance Agency is an independent insurance office located in Warsaw, IN. We strive to empower each of our clients by offering products sold by regional and national insurers at the best price. Each package we offer includes very competitive home, auto, health, and life rates for individuals and families. We represent companies that provide multi-policy discounts that help keep your premiums affordable while also promising to educate you on exactly what your policy entails. We want you to be covered when you need it and understanding is the first step.

Clevenger Insurance also has access to competitive markets that will insure almost every business at a rate you can be happy with. As an independent agency, we will secure all of the promises you have been given from the companies we have aligned ourselves with. Our goal is to encourage you, the customer, because Warsaw was meant to be lived, worked, and played in. There is no time in-between to worry about your coverage, and we vow that with our service and rates there will be a policy that best suits you.


Auto Insurance

Home might be where the heart is, but you spend a lot of your time in your car. Let us help you protect yourself, your passengers, and your vehicle. We can help you find auto insurance that fits your budget.

Get a Free Quote

Auto Insurance logo


Home Insurance

Your home is where everything happens. Make sure your home is fully protected from disaster and danger. We’re here to make sure you can keep on celebrating and living your life, no matter what happens.

Get a Free Quote

Home logo


Business Insurance

Your business is your stamp on the world. You’ve taken your dreams from idea to reality and built something bigger than yourself. Keep your business safe and on track with the right business insurance policy. We can help you find the right fit for your company.

Get a Free Quote

Business logo


Employee Benefits

Your employees keep your business running and help it grow. Keep your employees happy, healthy, and whole with a comprehensive employee benefits plan. We can help you create the right package for your business, your employees, and your budget.

Get a Free Quote

Employee Benefits logo


Life Insurance

No one wants to think about their own death, so don’t. Instead, focus on life -- the lives of your loved ones. Life insurance is your last opportunity to take care of your family. Your life insurance policy will be with them when you can’t be. We can help you find the right policy for your life and beyond.

Get a Free Quote

Life logo


Clevenger Insurance is committed

to making our community a better place to live and to protect your tomorrow today.

why background image

Clevenger Insurance Agency is here to stay and gives back to the community through involvement in: The Optimist Club, Kosciusko Community Foundation, United Way, Salvation Army Committee, Elementary Reading Program, and two terms as a Winona Lake Town Councilman.

Get A Free Quote


What They Say

The program Clevenger Insurance proposed was a self-insured program with high member engagement – and a strategy to change the culture and thought of our benefit program. While change can be jarring not just on the executive team, but also employees – the transition has been well worth it.

Burke L

Clevenger Insurance takes the complexity out of insurance.

Jenn G

As the key person in handling insurance renewal, insurance certificates, additions and changes, I have no complaints with Clevenger Insurance Agency. They are great to work with, and I would recommend them to anyone!

Michelle M

From the start, Gina Clevenger and her team were quick to respond to our needs. They provided us several different options for group health insurance and explained the features and benefits of each option. Although our company doesn’t welcome change, everyone was in agreement Clevenger Insurance was a company we wanted to work with particularly because of their responsiveness to our needs and the comfort level we have with them. They walked us through each step of the process and surprisingly it was easy. Because we switched to Clevenger Insurance we were able to cut our group health insurance cost by 56%!

Amanda H

Being busy as a working mom - I was ecstatic Clevenger gave me a quote over the phone the first time I called in! The team at Clevenger make it so easy to do business with them and really care for you as a person!

Katie C

If it wasn’t for Clevenger , I would have bought state minimum limits on my auto insurance. But Clevenger educated me on why I needed a higher liability limit so I was better protected. There is no cost to peace of mind!

Jessie E

I moved here from the West Coast and was surprisingly thrilled how easy Clevenger Insurance set up all new policies. I went with Clevenger because every year I can expect a call to make sure I stay informed of all my insurance options.

Joey D